Order Online

Call us @

608-839-3102


       



Bacon Cheeseburger

Bacon Cheeseburger

Ranch sauce, topped with ground beef, bacon, mozzarella & cheddar. Cooked. Then additionally topped with lettuce, tomato, onion & pickles

JR. - $8.29
10 - $16.99
12 - $20.99
14 - $24.99
16 - $27.99
Taco

Taco

Lathered w/ a blend of refried beans & taco sauce, topped w/ ground beef, mozzarella & cheddar. Cooked. Then topped w/ lettuce, tomato & tortilla chips. Served w/ sour cream & taco sauce on the side

JR. - $8.29
10 - $16.99
12 - $20.99
14 - $24.99
16 - $27.99
Bellybuster

Bellybuster

Pizza sauce, topped with pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushroom, onion, green pepper, black olives & mozzarella

JR. - $8.29
10 - $16.99
12 - $20.99
14 - $24.99
16 - $27.99
Vegetarian

Vegetarian

Pizza sauce, topped with mushroom, onion, green pepper, black olive, tomato & mozzarella

JR. - $7.99
10 - $15.99
12 - $19.99
14 - $23.99
16 - $26.99

Gutbuster

Pizza sauce, topped with mushroom, onion, green pepper, Italian sausage & mozzarella

JR. - $7.99
10 - $15.99
12 - $19.99
14 - $23.99
16 - $26.99
Chicken Rancher

Chicken Rancher

Ranch sauce, topped with mushroom, onion, tomato, bacon, diced chicken, mozzarella & cheddar cheese

JR. - $8.29
10 - $16.99
12 - $20.99
14 - $24.99
16 - $27.99
Mac & Cheese

Mac & Cheese

Lathered with garlic butter & cheddar cheese sauce, topped with homemade mac & cheese, mozzarella & cheddar, sprinkled with parmesan & black pepper

JR. - $7.99
10 - $15.99
12 - $19.99
14 - $23.99
16 - $26.99
Hawaiian

Hawaiian

Pizza sauce, topped with Canadian bacon, pineapple, tomato & mozzarella (Try it with our sweet BBQ sauce)

JR. - $7.99
10 - $15.99
12 - $19.99
14 - $23.99
16 - $26.99

Bucky Special

Pizza sauce, topped with extra mushroom, Italian sausage, mozzarella & extra cheddar cheese

JR. - $7.99
10 - $15.99
12 - $19.99
14 - $23.99
16 - $26.99

Chicken Deluxe

Pizza sauce, topped with mushroom, onion, green pepper, diced chicken & mozzarella

JR. - $7.99
10 - $15.99
12 - $19.99
14 - $23.99
16 - $26.99
BBQ Chicken

BBQ Chicken

Sweet BBQ sauce, topped with mushroom, onion, diced chicken & mozzarella

JR. - $7.99
10 - $15.99
12 - $19.99
14 - $23.99
16 - $26.99
Meat Deluxe

Meat Deluxe

Pizza sauce, topped with Italian sausage, pepperoni, bacon, ground beef & mozzarella

JR. - $7.99
10 - $15.99
12 - $19.99
14 - $23.99
16 - $26.99
Chicken Alfredo

Chicken Alfredo

Alfredo sauce, topped with fresh garlic, spinach, onion, tomato, bacon, chicken & mozzarella

JR. - $8.29
10 - $16.99
12 - $20.99
14 - $24.99
16 - $27.99
Margarita Pizza

Margarita Pizza

Garlic butter sauce, then topped with fresh garlic, spinach, tomato, oregano & mozzarella

JR. - $7.99
10 - $15.99
12 - $19.99
14 - $23.99
16 - $26.99
Thick Crust (Hand Tossed)

Thick Crust (Hand Tossed)

10 - $10.99
12 - $13.99
14 - $16.99
16 - $18.99
Thin Crust

Thin Crust

10 - $10.99
12 - $13.99
14 - $16.99
16 - $18.99

Additional Toppings

10 - $1.29
12 - $1.59
14 - $1.89
16 - $2.29
Deep Dish

Deep Dish

Junior - $5.99
Medium - $16.99
Large - $18.99

Additional Toppings

Junior - $0.59
Medium - $1.89
Large - $2.29
Calzone

Calzone

Your favorite pizza with a twist

Just Cheese - $8.49
Specialty Tier 1 - $12.99
Additional Toppings - $1.25
Specialty Tier 2 - $13.99
10

10" Gluten Free Pizza

Your go-to cauliflower crust

10 - $13.99
Additional Toppings - $1.25

Italian Sausage, Pepperoni, Ground Beef, Canadian Bacon, Diced All White Chicken, Ham, Real Bacon, Fresh Mushrooms, Onion, Green Pepper, Black Olive, Green Olive, Tomato, Pineapple, Cheddar Cheese, Jalapeno Pepper, Banana Pepper, Fresh Garlic and Spinach.




Cheese Curds

Cheese Curds

White Wisconsin cheddar cheese curds lightly dusted with a golden coating

Single - $6.99
Double - $12.99
Fried Pickles

Fried Pickles

Fresh garden pickles, thick sliced in a golden breading, dusted with bits of sweet basil & hints of garlic. Served best w/ our spicy avocado ranch

Single - $7.99
Breadsticks

Breadsticks

Freshly baked smothered with garlic butter & parmesan served with marinara

Small (5) - $6.49
Large (10) - $10.49
Cheese Bread

Cheese Bread

Our garlic bread topped with mozzarella baked to perfection

$5.99

Garlic Bread

Baked & smothered with garlic butter

$3.99
Zesty Cheese Breadsticks

Zesty Cheese Breadsticks

Our cheese sticks sprinkled with our zesty seasoning blend

Small (5) - $7.99
Large (10) - $12.49
Cheese Breadsticks

Cheese Breadsticks

Our breadsticks topped with mozzarella baked to perfection

Small (5) - $7.99
Large (10) - $12.49
Cinnamon Sticks

Cinnamon Sticks

Freshly baked smothered with butter & cinnamon sugar served with our homemade frosting

Small (5) - $6.49
Large (10) - $10.99
The Pizza Melt

The Pizza Melt

Our garlic bread, spread with pizza sauce, served with toppings of your choice and mozzarella

Just Cheese - $7.99
Add Toppings - $0.79

French Fries

A fluffy, buttery potato flavor on the inside and a crisp, textured exterior

Side - $2.99
Large - $4.99
Mozzarella Sticks

Mozzarella Sticks

7 crispy and delicious sticks made with real Wisconsin mozzarella. Served w/ our signature marinara

$7.99

Fried Cheesy Ravioli

Crispy, delicate pasta pocket filled with melted ricotta cheese. Served w/ our signature marinara

$8.49

Chicken Wings

A mixture of drummies and paddles by the pound, served naked with your choice of dipping sauce

1lb (6-10) - $10.99
2lb (12-20) - $21.49
Spicy Chicken Bites

Spicy Chicken Bites

Hot & spicy bite sized chunks of chicken. Served by 3/4 of a pound with your choice of dipping sauce

$10.99

Chicken Strips

Crispy, juicy tenderness & seasoned to perfection. Served at 10 ounces an order (3-5) with your choice of dipping sauce

$9.99

Bag O' Chips

Miss Vickie's Sea Salt, Doritos Nacho Cheese, Lays Sour Cream & Onion

$1.49

Nacho Cheese • Honey Mustard • Ranch • BBQ • Red Hot Sauce • Garlic Butter • Marinara • Spicy Avocado Ranch • Flaming Honey Garlic
Extra Sauce: $0.79 Each




All pasta dinners are served with your choice of Garlic Bread, Bread Sticks, Cheese Bread, or Cheese Sticks

Homemade Lasagna

Homemade Lasagna

Ribbon noodles with italian sausage, veggies & a four cheese blend, smothered in our signature marinara

$11.99

Jumbo Ravioli

Six jumbo pieces of beef or cheese raviolis smothered in our signature marinara sauce

$10.99

Spaghetti

Classic spaghetti noodles covered in our signature marinara sauce

$8.99
Add Meatballs - $2.00

Mac & Cheese

Our signature homemade macaroni & cheese sprinkled with parmesan & black pepper

$9.99

Try Any Pasta "Baked"!

Topped with mozzarella, baked to perfection

$2.00



8" White or Wheat Hoagies
All cold subs include lettuce, tomato, onion, provolone cheese, mayonnaise, and seasonings.

Our subs are excellent hot and toasted straight from our oven!
You can try your sub toasted today for only $0.50 extra!

Ham

#1

Cold - $7.99
Toasted - $8.49

Turkey

#2

Cold - $7.99
Toasted - $8.49

Tuna

#3

Cold - $7.99
Toasted - $8.49

Meatball

#4
Toasted hoagie filled with meatballs, mozzarella, marinara, green pepper & onion

Toasted - $8.49

Club

#5
Ham & Turkey

Cold - $7.99
Toasted - $8.49

Italian

#6
Salami, Capicola, & Italian Dressing

Cold - $7.99
Toasted - $8.49

Vegetarian

#7
Everything plus green pepper, mushroom, & black olive

Cold - $7.99
Toasted - $8.49

B.L.T.

#8
Toasted hoagie topped with bacon, provolone, mayo, lettuce, tomato, black pepper & oregano

Toasted - $8.49
Papa's Special

Papa's Special

#9
Oven toasted with Italian beef, pasta sauce, onion, green pepper, & mozzarella

Toasted - $9.49

Chicago Italian Beef

#10
Toasted hoagie topped with Italian beef, provolone, garlic butter, sauteed onions & peppers. Served w/ a side of au jus sauce & giardiniera

Toasted - $9.49

Toasted Chicken

#11
Toasted hoagie topped with diced chicken, provolone, mayo, lettuce, tomato, onion, black pepper & oregano

Toasted - $9.49

Chicken Bacon Rancher

#12
Toasted hoagie topped with diced chicken, bacon, provolone, ranch, lettuce, tomato, onion, black pepper & oregano

Toasted - $9.49



All salads are served with Tomato, Onion, Black Olive, Mushroom, Green Pepper and Cheddar Cheese

Small Salad

Individual Size

Regular - $6.99
Add Meat - $1.50

Large Salad

Serves 2-3 people

Regular - $13.99
Add Meat - $2.50



Can of Soda

Can of Soda

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Diet MTN Dew, Starry, A&W Root Beer, Wild Cherry Pepsi

$1.59
Six Pack of Soda

Six Pack of Soda

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Diet MTN Dew, Starry, A&W Root Beer, Wild Cherry Pepsi

$6.99
2-Liter of Soda

2-Liter of Soda

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Diet MTN DEW, Mug Root Beer, Starry & Sugar Free Starry

$4.19
Juice Boxes

Juice Boxes

Apple, Berry, Orange, and Grape

$1.19

Milk

Available for dine in only.

$1.29
Pure Leaf Lemon Tea

Pure Leaf Lemon Tea

Brewed from REAL leaves. 0 Calories.

$2.99
Pure Leaf Sweet Tea

Pure Leaf Sweet Tea

Made from REAL leaves. 0 Calories.

$2.99
Hog Wash Red

Hog Wash Red

$1.99
Hog Wash Blue

Hog Wash Blue

$1.99
Mtn. Dew Kickstart Energizing Black Cherry

Mtn. Dew Kickstart Energizing Black Cherry

$2.99

Seasonal Beer & Wine

Dine-in only




Pint

Pint

$7.25
Quart

Quart

$13.50
Kids Scoop

Kids Scoop

$3.90
Single Scoop

Single Scoop

$4.50
Double Scoop

Double Scoop

$6.00
Triple Scoop

Triple Scoop

$7.50
Single Waffle

Single Waffle

$5.50
Double Waffle

Double Waffle

$7.00
Cookie Sandwich

Cookie Sandwich

We're now serving many different flavored sandwich's! Try them rolled in a candy topping!

Regular - $5.75
Rolled - $6.45
Chocolate Chip Cookie

Chocolate Chip Cookie

$0.75
Three Cookie Special

Three Cookie Special

$2.00

Chocolate, Vanilla, Specialty, Strawberry

Shakes & Malts

Dutch Maid Vanilla ice cream, milk & flavoring blended to perfection

Regular - $8.00
Extra Thick - $8.75
Specialty Shake

Specialty Shake

Your favorite specialty flavor & milk blended to perfection

$8.50

Twister

Dutch Maid Vanilla ice cream mixed with your favorite candy. Reese's, Oreo, M&M's, Brownie, Dark Chocolate Chips or Sprinkles.

$8.50

Root Beer Float

Dutch Maid Vanilla & Mug Root beer

$5.50

Small Hot Fudge/Caramel

Dutch Maid Vanilla ice cream topped with hot fudge or caramel, whipped cream & a cherry

$5.50

Large Hot Fudge/Caramel

Dutch Maid Vanilla ice cream topped with hot fudge or caramel, whipped cream & a cherry

$7.00

Small Turtle

Dutch Maid Vanilla ice cream topped with chocolate sauce, caramel, pecans, whipped cream, & a cherry

$6.00

Large Turtle

Dutch Maid Vanilla ice cream topped with chocolate sauce, caramel, pecans, whipped cream, & a cherry

$7.50

YEAR ROUND: Cotton Candy, Turtle, Vanilla, Chocolate, Ultimate Oreo, Butter Pecan, Cookie Dough, Blue Moon, Heaps Of Love, Peanut Butter Cup, Mint Avalanche, Coconut Almond Bliss, Peanut Butter Cookie Dough, Zoreo, Zanzibar
SEASONAL: Raspberry Rhapsody, This Just Got Serious, Kitty Kitty Bang Bang, Superman, Munchie Madness, Fat Elvis, Eggnog, Lemon Meringue
COFFEE FLAVORS: Expresso Oreo, Exhausted Parent, Cappuccino Break




One Regular Slice

Pepperoni or Sausage

$3.50

Two Regular Slices

$6.00

One Special Slice

Changes Daily

$4.50

Two Special Slices

$8.50

One Regular & Special Slice

$7.50

Two Breadsticks

$2.00

24oz Fountain Drink

$1.50

8" Sub & Chips

$9.50

8" Sub & Fries

$11.00

8" Sub & Curds

$14.50

20oz Fountain Drink

$1.50

We serve fresh slices and other combos for Dine-in and Carry-out only, from 11am-2pm Monday through Friday.




Copyright 2007-2024 Papa Jimmy's Pizzeria