Order Online

Call us @



Papa Jimmy’s is a family-owned pizzeria serving Cottage Grove, Wisconsin, and its surrounding areas since 1995. Along with catering options, we also have space available for birthday parties and business meetings. For more information, just give us a call!

Papa Jimmy’s as a place families could dine in or carry out one-of-a-kind pizza in the Cottage Grove area was the vision of Jim Spalding, originally from Monona, Wisconsin. During his time at the Culinary Arts Program at Madison College, Jim worked at various pizzerias, where he developed an appreciation for the fast-paced business atmosphere. During this time, Jim saw the vacancy of an established pizzeria out in the Cottage Grove area -- where no other pizza outlet would even deliver to -- and decided Cottage Grove would be the perfect spot to open Papa Jimmy’s. And in 1995, he did just that.

Since then, Jim, his wife, Pam, and their 3 children have established Papa Jimmy’s as one of the top pizzeria locations in the Cottage Grove area. Winning numerous “Best of” awards for their menu selections, Papa Jimmy’s is the perfect place for lunch or dinner. Because they use only the freshest ingredients, homemade sauce, and pizza dough made right there at the restaurant, you can always taste the Papa Jimmy's difference.

The Spaldings live in Cottage Grove and are actively involved in the community. From their always visible presence at school and community events at any time of year, there's no question that Papa Jimmy's has earned its reputation as Cottage Grove's favorite pizzeria.

Copyright 2007-2024 Papa Jimmy's Pizzeria