Order Now

608-839-3102

Hours
Sunday - Thursday: 11AM-9PM
Friday: 11AM-11PM
Saturday: 11AM-10:30PM

Deals Lunch Specials Delivery Area        



Cheeseburger

Cheeseburger

Ranch, Ground Beef, Bacon, Cheddar, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion and Pickles!

JR. - $5.99
10" - $13.95
12" - $16.95
14" - $19.95
16" - $22.95
Taco

Taco

Beans, Ground Beef, Cheddar Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Tortilla Chips

JR. - $5.99
10" - $13.95
12" - $16.95
14" - $19.95
16" - $22.95
Belly Buster

Belly Buster

Sausage, Pepperoni, Mushroom, Onion, Green Pepper and Black Olive

JR. - $5.99
10" - $13.95
12" - $16.95
14" - $19.95
16" - $22.95
Veggie

Veggie

Mushroom, Onion, Black Olive, Green Pepper and Tomatoes

JR. - $5.69
10 - $12.75
12 - $15.75
14 - $18.75
16 - $21.75

Gutbuster

Sausage, Mushroom, Onion and Green Pepper

JR. - $5.69
10 - $12.75
12 - $15.75
14 - $18.75
16 - $21.75
Mac & Cheese

Mac & Cheese

Cheddar Cheese Sauce, Mac & Cheese, Shredded Cheddar & Mozzarella Cheese, with Special Seasoning

JR. - $5.69
10" - $12.75
12" - $15.75
14" - $18.75
16" - $21.75
Chicken Rancher

Chicken Rancher

Mushroom, Onion, Tomato, Real Bacon and Diced Chicken

JR. - $5.69
10" - $12.75
12" - $15.75
14" - $18.75
16" - $21.75
Hawaiian

Hawaiian

Canadian Bacon, Pineapple and Tomato (Try it w/ our Sweet BBQ as the sauce!)

JR. - $5.69
10" - $12.75
12" - $15.75
14" - $18.75
16" - $21.75

Bucky Special

Mushroom, Sausage, Cheddar and Mozzarella Cheese

JR. - $5.69
10" - $12.75
12" - $15.75
14" - $18.75
16" - $21.75

Chicken Deluxe

Mushroom, Onion, Green Pepper and Diced Chicken

JR. - $5.69
10" - $12.75
12" - $15.75
14" - $18.75
16" - $21.75

BBQ Chicken

BBQ Sauce, Mushroom, Onion and Diced Chicken

JR. - $5.69
10" - $12.75
12" - $15.75
14" - $18.75
16" - $21.75

Meat Deluxe

Sausage, Pepperoni, Bacon and Ground Beef

JR. - $5.69
10" - $12.75
12" - $15.75
14" - $18.75
16" - $21.75
Chicken Alfredo

Chicken Alfredo

Alfredo sauce, Onion, Fresh Garlic, Bacon, Diced Chicken, and Tomatoes

JR. - $5.69
10" - $12.75
12" - $15.75
14" - $18.75
16" - $21.75
Thick Crust

Thick Crust

10" - $8.75
12" - $10.95
14" - $12.95
16" - $14.75
Thin Crust

Thin Crust

10" - $8.75
12" - $10.95
14" - $12.95
16" - $14.75

Additional Toppings

10" - $1.25
12" - $1.55
14" - $1.85
16" - $2.25
Deep Dish

Deep Dish

Junior - $4.19
Medium - $12.95
Large - $14.75

Additional Toppings

Junior - $0.49
Medium - $1.85
Large - $2.25
Calzone

Calzone

Your favorite pizza with a twist!

BellyBuster - $10.99
Mac n Cheese - $9.99
BBQ Chicken - $9.99
Cheese - $6.49
Additional Toppings - $0.99

Italian Sausage, Pepperoni, Ground Beef, Canadian Bacon, Diced All White Chicken, Ham, Real Bacon, Fresh Mushrooms, Onion, Green Pepper, Black Olive, Green Olive, Tomato, Pineapple, Cheddar Cheese, Jalapeno Pepper, Banana Pepper, Fresh Garlic and Spinach.




Cheese Curds

Cheese Curds

Single Order - $5.59
Double Order - $8.59
Bread Sticks

Bread Sticks

Regular Order - $3.79
Large Order - $6.29
Cheese Bread

Cheese Bread

$4.29

Garlic Bread

$2.79

Cheese Bread Sticks

Regular Order - $4.99
Large Order - $8.49

Cinnamon Sticks

Regular Order - $3.99
Large Order - $6.49

Pizza Bread

Cheese - $4.29
Extra Toppings - $0.49

French Fries

Regular Order - $1.99
Large Order - $3.29
Mozzarella Sticks

Mozzarella Sticks

$5.99

Chicken Wings

1 LB / Regular - $7.99
2 LB / Large - $15.49
Spicy Sriracha Chicken Bites

Spicy Sriracha Chicken Bites

$6.99

Chicken Strips

$6.99

Bag 'O Chips

$0.95

Nacho Cheese, Honey Mustard, BBQ, Ranch, Red Hot Sauce

Extra Sauce: $0.49 Each




All pasta dinners are served with your choice of Garlic Bread or Bread Sticks

Homemade Lasagna

Homemade Lasagna

$7.99

Jumbo Ravioli

Your choice of Beef or Cheese.

$7.99

Spaghetti

Regular Order - $6.49
With Meatballs - $7.49

Baked Spaghetti

Regular Order - $6.99
With Meatballs - $8.99



8" White or Wheat Hoagies
All cold subs include lettuce, tomato, onion, provolone cheese, mayonnaise, and seasonings.

Our subs are excellent hot and toasted straight from our oven!
You can try your sub toasted today for only $0.30 extra!

Ham

#1

Cold - $5.49
Toasted - $5.79

Turkey

#2

Cold - $5.49
Toasted - $5.79

Tuna

#3

Cold - $5.49
Toasted - $5.79

Roast Beef

#4

Cold - $5.49
Toasted - $5.79

Meatball

#5
Oven toasted with onion, green pepper, pasta sauce & mozzarella cheese

Toasted - $5.79

Club

#6
Ham & Turkey

Cold - $5.49
Toasted - $5.79

Italian

#7
Salami, Capicola, & Italian Dressing

Cold - $5.49
Toasted - $5.79

Vegetarian

#9
Black Olive, Green Pepper

Cold - $5.49
Toasted - $5.79

B.L.T.

#9
Oven toasted with Real Bacon

Toasted - $5.79
Papa's Special

Papa's Special

#10
Oven toasted with Roast Beef, pasta sauce, onion, green pepper, & mozzarella

Toasted - $5.79

Chicago Italian Beef

Oven Toasted with Fresh Italian Beef, Provolone Cheese, Sauteed Onions and Green Peppers. Served with Giardiniera and PJ's Au Jus Sauce.

Toasted - $6.19



All salads are served with Tomato, Onion, Black Olive, Mushroom, Green Pepper and Cheddar Cheese

Small Salad

$4.49
With Meat - $5.74

Large Salad

$7.99
With Meat - $9.98



Can of Soda

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Sprite, A&W Root Beer, Wild Cherry Pepsi, Diet Wild Cherry Pepsi

$0.99

Six Pack of Soda

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Sprite, A&W Root Beer, Wild Cherry Pepsi, Diet Wild Cherry Pepsi

$4.19

2-Liter of Soda

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, A&W Root Beer

$2.59

Juice Boxes

$0.99

Milk

Available for dine in only.

$1.29

Seasonal Beer & Wine




Pint

$5.25

Quart

$9.75

Kids, Single, Double, Triple

Kids Dish/Sugar or Wafer Cone

Kids Dish/Sugar or Wafer Cone

$2.65
Single Dish/Sugar or Wafer Cone

Single Dish/Sugar or Wafer Cone

$3.32
Double Dish/Sugar or Wafer Cone

Double Dish/Sugar or Wafer Cone

$4.60
Triple Dish/Sugar or Wafer Cone

Triple Dish/Sugar or Wafer Cone

$5.59

Single Waffle Cone

$4.25

Double Waffle Cone

$5.21

Cookie Sandwich

$3.98

Single Cookie

$0.59

Chocolate, Vanilla, Specialty, Strawberry

Shakes & Malts

Regular - $5.21
Extra Thick - $5.71

Specialty Shake

What makes it a specialty?? Making a shake with any ice cream other than vanilla or chocolate.

$4.98

Twister

$5.29

Root Beer Float

$3.98

Hot Fudge, Turtle, Caramel

Small Hot Fudge/Caramel

$3.98

Large Hot Fudge/Caramel

$4.98

Small Turtle

$4.50

Large Turtle

$5.50

YEAR ROUND: Cotton Candy, Turtle, Vanilla, Chocolate, Ultimate Oreo, Butter Pecan, Cookie Dough, Blue Moon, Heaps Of Love, Peanut Butter Cup, Mint Avalanche, Coconut Almond Bliss, Peanut Butter Cookie Dough, Zoreo, Zanzibar
SEASONAL: Raspberry Rhapsody, This Just Got Serious, Kitty Kitty Bang Bang, Superman, Munchie Madness, Fat Elvis, Eggnog, Lemon Meringue
COFFEE FLAVORS: Expresso Oreo, Exhausted Parent, Cappuccino Break

Brownies, Oreos, Reeses Peanut Butter Cup, M&Ms, Take 5




One Regular Slice & Soda

$4.27

Two Regular Slices & Soda

$5.69

One Slice of the Day & Soda

$4.98

Two Slices of the Day & Soda

$7.02

One Slice of the Day, One Regular Slice & Soda

$6.54

One Topping Junior Pizza & Soda

$5.98

Specialty Junior Pizza & Soda

$7.80

One Topping Pizza Bread & Soda

$6.50

One Topping Calzone & Soda

$8.76

Specialty Calzone & Soda

$11.29

8" Sub & Soda

$6.88

8" Sub, Chips & Soda

$7.58

8" Sub, Fries & Soda

$7.99

8" Sub, Cheese Curds & Soda

$11.99

Chicken Strips, Fries & Soda

$9.99

Chicken Strips, Cheese Curds & Soda

$13.59

Chicken Wings, Fries & Soda

$10.99

Chicken Wings, Cheese Curds & Soda

$14.59

Lasagna & Soda

$9.29

Spaghetti & Soda

$7.49

Spaghetti with Meatballs & Soda

$8.79

Baked Spaghetti & Soda

$9.79

Baked Spaghetti with Meatballs & Soda

$9.79

Jumbo Cheese Ravioli & Soda

$9.29

Jumbo Beef Ravioli & Soda

$9.29

Add a Side Salad for just $3.95!
Add a small Breadsticks for just $3.79.
All Toasted Subs + $0.30

We serve fresh slices and all other meal deals from 11am - 2pm, Monday through Friday.




Copyright 2007-2017 Papa Jimmy's Pizzeria

224 W. Cottage Grove Rd
Cottage Grove, WI 53527